Markets Marked Down

It’s been interesting to watch the whole Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac business in America become perhaps an example of losing trust in ‘the market’ and the belief that ‘the market’ will always be able to self manage.

As a republican government who would traditionally espouse small government exercising few regulatory controls and a free market left alone as much as possible to do what it wants to do moves to effectively nationalize the failing mortgage lenders at the cost of hundreds of billions of dollars of tax payers money then you have to wonder about how we may in future place stricter controls on how the free market operates. Do we need the market to be slightly less free?

Radio 4’s point of view recently gave time to Katharine Whitehorn’s view of the market as she questioned the blind faith many put in it as system that could always deliver the most efficient results.

She says:

It’s not just the markets as such, though that make me grind my teeth; market forces may be fine when they apply only to the markets. It’s the conviction that commercial principles are always the most efficient; that anything done for private profit and in competition must always be better and more effective than anything done for any other fudsy old reason such as the common good.

Once we wanted right-wing economics and left-wing social policy. Now it’s the other way round

I was also interested to read a piece via The First Post on Sunday by Phillip Blond some time ago under the attention grabbing title reproduced here.Well, attention grabbing to me anyway.
Blond argues that the neo liberal social policy in Britain can be seen by many to have failed on many levels we find that the right wing economic beliefs are equally not standing up to scrutiny as the credit crunch and global recession begin to bite, food and energy prices increase month on month and the divisions between rich and poor become even wider as social mobility returns to post WWII levels.

In Britain which more  than the rest of Europe has embraced right wing economic policy the breaking up and selling off of the previously nationalised industries has not resulted in dramatically better and affordable services for the consumer. It can be reasonably argued that without government controls the free market would further maximise profits to shareholders, reducing further any investment in infrastructure which it still often expects central government to fund (didn’t government spin these things off in order to unburden the cost to the public purse & hopefully bring private investment on a scale government could not afford?.

Regulating The Market

So how do we get the free market to deliver what we the consumer wants without government having to continually bail out its excesses & legislate against its more unethical and selfish aspects.

Some industries have benefited from private management whilst others (perhaps notably public transport and the various utility and energy companies in the UK ) have ultimately failed to deliver greater choice and a better service than their state owned predecessors.When selling off the public utilities was first floated during Harold Macillan’s time as Conservative Prime Minister he dismissed the idea as akin to selling off the family silver.

Phillip Blond further argues that neither the left or the right has been able to do anything very effective about the poor (or for that matter, the needy) and so the idea of the government employing them directly becomes an idea that has never been quite been tried before.

A New Era?

Personally I’d prefer that the regulation needed to keep a free market in check were made by independent bodies of regulators rather than solely by government that is prone to force through opportunistic legislation with an eye to beefing up their by election or general election prospects rather than soberly regulating independently of that.

So are we entering a new global period in which a greater government intervention in the operation of the free market will now be necessary. A new era of balancing right wing economic policy with left wing social policy?

Photo by charles.hope under this creative commons license

AddThis Social Bookmark Button


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s